For many decades in American politics political leaders have been able to engage in what political scientists call the politics of distribution. As the economy grew the income and social security taxes generated a growing pool of tax revenue that could then be used to fund an enlarged safety net, and reward constituencies and interest groups without continually raising taxes. This made it possible to fund demands for farm and business subsidies, medical care, food and housing assistance for the elderly and poor, tax expenditures for corporations and the middle class, and increased defense expenditures all without significantly raising rates. The position of the dollar as the world's reserve currency and our good credit rating allowed us to borrow in the world markets when tax revenues fell short or distributive demands exceeded the willingness to raise taxes.
This period of economic growth and the practice of the politics of distribution has had a number of consequences for our political and economic system. It allowed us to create and maintain a safety net for those who cannot compete in our economy for a variety of reasons such as age, disability, child rearing responsibilities, etc. This safety net coupled with the earned income tax credit for working poor shifted some labor costs to the government, enabled businesses to pay lower wages and benefits and hence be more competitive and retain higher profits. Growing tax revenue allowed government to make significant investments in our economic infrastructure such as education and transportation and allowed us to use financial incentives rather than just government regulations to get private citizens to engage in socially and environmentally responsible behaviors. In macroeconomic terms, these government expenditures also acted as automatic stabilizers supporting consumer demand in economy and stimulating economic growth during times of economic downturns.
On the political side, the era of distributive politics encouraged the growth of interest group politics and rising campaign expenditures as people organized to get and maintain a share of the growing revenues. Each success in getting a share of the pie also led to the creation of new bureaucracies to implement these programs. The mutual interests of special interest groups, committees in Congress and bureaucracies entrenched these new distributive policies making change politically very difficult.
However, the financial crisis of 2008 may be ushering in a new era of politics--the politics of redistribution. Bush era tax cuts, the collapse of the housing market in 2007-08 and the subsequent debt crisis and recession have dramatically reduced government revenue. As the ranks of the unemployed reach post depression highs safety net expenditures have increased dramatically and unfunded war expenditures have yet to decline. This economic crisis has come at the same time the growing numbers of baby boomers are retiring. As a result we are faced with much higher expenditures, much lower tax revenue and a rapidly growing national debt.
In 2011 federal government expenditures will be about 25% of GDP, up from about 19% in 2000 while tax revenue has fallen from 20% to 16% of GDP in the same time period. The result has been a ballooning federal deficit with the national debt growing from 39% of GDP in 2000 to nearly 99% of our GDP in 2011.. It seems apparent that this rate of growth in our debt cannot continue much longer.
There are really only three ways government can respond to this problem--raising taxes, reducing expenditures or stimulating economic growth. In the short term, government distributive policies to stimulate economic growth, whether in the form of tax cuts or increased spending, are likely to add even more to the debt burden. Hence it seems we are faced with a politics of redistribution. The Republican approach of stimulating growth through even more tax cuts while cutting social expenditures is clearly a policy of redistributing wealth from those receiving government benefits to those currently paying the most taxes. Democratic policies seeking tax increases to preserve social expenditures redistribute in the opposite direction. Reform of the tax code will also involve redistribution of current government benefits.
This creates a very difficult and divisive political climate since the ability of one group to preserve or increase its benefits must reduce the benefits available to other groups. It has been much easier and less divisive for elected politicians to put more ornaments on the Christmas tree of public benefits and reward diverse interest groups than to remove or redistribute them. It may also eventually reshape American politics along class lines and reduce the influence of special interest groups. One could argue that the safety net and other government benefits for lower income Americans were a product of an era of economic abundance where rising revenues allowed such programs to be put into place without directly redistributing wealth from the "haves" of society. In effect, it allowed a win-win outcome. Everyone's income and wealth could grow at the same time.
Now the ability to preserve or obtain government benefits will depend even more on getting and increasing political power. For lower classes in Europe that historically involved the formation of class based political parties, labor and social movements. As we move into an era of greater scarcity the politics of redistribution will force lower and middle classes to organize and provide an incentive for elites to mobilize voters on the basis of class interests.
President Obama came into office with the hope of pursuing a politics of compromise and conciliation with Republicans and instead found a party increasingly dominated by a class-based ideology of the "haves". The influence of the Tea Party in the 2008 elections has made it even more difficult for Republicans to pursue the former politics of distribution with its compromises over benefits and burdens. The President now seems to be adopting a more class-based policy, too. While Republicans will argue that President Obama is playing the class card, it should be clear that the politics of redistribution is leading both parties to move toward class based policies.
Over the years, Republicans have covered their bias toward upper classes by trying to focus elections on social issues such as fear of communism, fear of unions, fear of crime, fear of affirmative action for women and minorities, fear of homosexuality, fear of immigration, Muslims, abortion, etc. These so-called "wedge" issues appealed to many traditional lower- middle class Democratic constituencies and divided this traditional Democratic voter base. However, economic issues such as prolonged unemployment, reduced opportunities for our young people, growing economic insecurity for the middle and lower classes and the increasing concentration of wealth in the upper classes are likely to override social issues as a concern for many voters and may well help overcome America's traditional aversion to class politics.
Hopefully President Obama will provide leadership to mobilize the interests of the lower and middle classes in the upcoming elections. If he and other Democrats can mobilize these classes around the politics of redistribution he may yet have a chance for re-election.